What did CFTC nominees say about prediction markets in Senate hearing?

CFTC nomination hearing
Fotokostic/Shutterstock

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Democratic CFTC nominee Matt Rowland told the Senate Agriculture Committee he is sympathetic to states and tribes in the sports event contracts debate.
  • Republican nominee Nathan Anonick declined to say whether a trade on an NFL game result is sports betting and committed to hearing from all sides.
  • The committee took no vote Tuesday, but Sen. Ben Ray Luján signaled both nominees likely will win confirmation during the lame-duck session.

The two candidates nominated to join the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) spent much of Tuesday’s Senate Agriculture Committee hearing answering for an agency that senators say focuses more on technology than on the farmers it was built to watch.

When the questions turned to prediction markets, Democratic nominee Matt Rowland gave states and tribes something they rarely hear from the CFTC under Chairman Michael Selig: sympathy.

“I am sympathetic to the points states and tribes have raised,” Rowland told Sen. Tina Smith (D-MN) during the hearing, while also noting that he could not comment much on active litigation.

Selig, a Republican, has been the only commissioner for nearly a year on what is supposed to be a five-seat, bipartisan commission. For most of that time, Selig has used his lone vote to back Kalshi, Polymarket and their competitors in asserting CFTC jurisdiction, including 12 lawsuits against states.

President Donald Trump nominated Rowland and Republican Nathan Anonick last week, nine days after Democrats won control of Congress during the midterm elections.

Smith questions CFTC sports jurisdiction

Minnesota became the first state to ban prediction markets in May, but Smith said prediction market operators still offer sports contracts to her constituents in the state. The CFTC sued Minnesota to block the law.

Smith said “the law is quite clear” on where jurisdiction over sports betting lies, pointing to the 2018 Murphy v. NCAA ruling, which returned the power to legalize sports betting to the states, and to tribes under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA).

Both nominees agreed that Murphy gave those powers as listed and that CFTC rules prohibit gaming contracts. Neither nominee weighed in on what might distinguish a sports wager from a sports event contract.

When Smith asked about the practical difference between the two, Rowland noted that “there have been courts that held both ways.” Anonick called it “a complex legal question that courts have disagreed” on and called the issue “very charged.”

That split is heading toward the U.S. Supreme Court. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals sided with Kalshi, while the Fourth, Sixth and Ninth Circuits sided with the states. Three petitions ask the justices to settle the question.

Schiff presses Anonick on sports contracts

Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA) called sports event contracts on prediction markets the “Wild West” of regulation. He said Selig promised to be a blank slate at his own confirmation, noting that Selig claimed he would look toward courts on prediction markets rulings, but now openly tells operators to defy court orders.

“I don’t know that I’ve ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before,” Schiff said.

CFTC Adam Schiff letter prediction markets
Philip Yabut/Shutterstock

Schiff led nine Democratic senators in a letter to Selig Monday demanding he reverse that order and to preserve communication since January 2025, when prediction markets started offering sports event contracts. 

The letter says it “directly conflicts with active court orders” in California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington. The senators gave Selig until Nov. 23 to respond.

Schiff asked Anonick directly whether a trade on the result of an NFL game counts as sports betting.

“I do think that question, from a legal perspective, is complex,” Anonick said. 

Pressed on whether he would defer to the courts or tell them what to do, he said he would rely on fact-finding with the general counsel, outside counsel, tribes, states and other stakeholders.

“I do not have a preconceived position because it would be irresponsible without going through that process,” Anonick said.

Warnock questions enforcement cuts, favoritism

Sen. Raphael Warnock (D-GA) asked about reduced enforcement and staff cuts at the agency. 

Warnock also raised concerns that the CFTC favors companies with ties to Trump. Rowland said the law must be enforced fairly. Anonick said laws must apply “equally and fairly to everyone involved.”

The committee record stays open for two days before any vote. Sen. Ben Ray Luján said during the hearing that both nominees will win confirmation.

No posts to display