A divided Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals sided with the state of Maryland on Tuesday, denying Kalshi‘s appeal of the state’s actions against the prediction markets operator.
A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 in favor of the state regulator, in a familiar case centered on whether sports event contracts meet the definition of a swap under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA). Kalshi lost for the third time in four Circuit Court appeals.
“Because the regulation of gambling has long been a matter of traditional state police power, I would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland’s concurrent authority absent a clear expression of its intent to do so,” wrote Judge Roger Gregory, an appointee of President Bill Clinton and George W. Bush, in his concurrence.
“Nor has Kalshi shown that complying with both the CEA and the Maryland law at issue would be impossible or stand as an obstacle to Congress’s objective to create a centralized federal regulatory framework for trading derivative contracts. I therefore conclude that Kalshi has not demonstrated that the CEA preempts Maryland’s sports wagering laws and concur in the judgment affirming the district court.”
Kalshi could ask for an en banc rehearing in the Fourth Circuit, as it did in previous losses at this level.
Kalshi decries ‘splintered’ Fourth Circuit denial
This loss differs from other two, though.
Kalshi lost unanimously at the Sixth and Ninth Circuit appeals courts. but Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin, a Biden appointee, broke from Gregory and Judge Stephanie Thacker, an Obama appointee, to dissent in the Fourth Circuit.
“The prevalence of prediction markets and swaps has undoubtably increased in recent years,” Benjamin concludes in her dissenting opinion.
“What hasn’t changed is Congress’ command that ‘exclusive jurisdiction’ over these swaps belongs to the CFTC. Because Kalshi’s sports-related contracts qualify as ‘swaps,’ I would conclude that Maryland’s laws are field preempted.”
A Kalshi spokesperson seized on the split to attack the decision.
“Judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong. This splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions, demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets,” reads a Kalshi statement provided to media.
Kalshi loved split Third Circuit victory
In April, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals delivered Kalshi its lone victory at the federal appellate, ruling that New Jersey gaming regulators could not ban sports event contracts in the Garden State.
As in the Fourth Circuit on Tuesday, the Third Circuit’s three-judge panel delivered a 2-1 ruling, this time favoring the prediction market in its quest to for Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) oversight.
But unlike in Tuesday’s response from Kalshi, co-founder and CEO Tarek Mansour did not mention the split in celebrating that triumph, instead simply calling it a “big win for the industry”:
Luana Lopes Lara, Mansour’s co-founder, similarly took a victory lap in April, with a nod at New Jersey:
Why did judges agree on Kalshi Maryland defeat?
Although Thacker aligned with Gregory, she made clear her decision rested on different principles.
“Although I ultimately concur in the bottom line opinion, that is, affirmance of the district court, I get there via a different route than does my concurring colleague,” Thacker said to open her opinion.
She later continued, “Indeed, Congress first defined swaps and placed them within the exclusive regulatory jurisdiction of the CFTC when it passed the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010. Notably, Congress enacted Dodd-Frank ‘in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis . . . to ‘promote the financial stability of the United States by improving accountability and transparency in the financial system.’
“Specifically, Congress enacted Dodd-Frank to ‘bring risky financial products out of the shadows that had threatened the stability of the entire U.S. financial sector, and which had catastrophic ripple effects on the U.S. and world economies during the financial crisis of 2007-2008.'”
“This stated purpose of Dodd-Frank has nothing to do with sports betting — because it clearly was not intended to give the federal government the exclusive prerogative to regulate sports betting. Therefore, I would hold that Appellant’s sporting event based contracts are not swaps, and I would affirm the district court on that basis.”













