KEY TAKEAWAYS
- A District Court judge sent the Kalshi NY case back to state court after the operator tried to move it into the federal judiciary, clearing a path for AG Letitia James.
- James filed Friday in New York’s Supreme Court for a show-cause hearing that would require Kalshi to prove why the $36bn enforcement actions sought by the state should not move forward.
- Kalshi attorneys responded to the initial Thursday remand by filing to prevent New York from taking emergency action against it.
The $36bn Kalshi NY case threatens to upend the US prediction markets economy if Friday’s show-cause filing by state Attorney General Letitia James ultimately favors the Empire State.
James asked Friday for Hon. Melissa Crane to grant a show-cause order requiring Kalshi to prove why the Supreme Court should not grant the attorney general’s demand to shut down not just the Kalshi NY business, but any commerce routed through the state.
The show-cause related to James’s suit seeking a temporary restraining order against Kalshi NY operations, as well as a preliminary and permanent injunction against the prediction markets company. Kalshi tried to move the suit to federal court because the operator purports it is rightfully overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), but Judge Vernon Broderick of the District
Court for the Southern District of New York kicked it back to the state level on Thursday.
That remand arrived two weeks after the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals denied Kalshi’s request for an injunction pending appeal of the state’s planned enforcement.
Kalshi originally lost its first attempt at stopping James on July 26, leading to the state’s pursuit five days later.
The Friday request for order refers to Kalshi as “operating an unlawful gambling business, or otherwise advancing gambling activity or profiting from gambling activity, within or from New York or to persons in New York, without being licensed by the New York State Gaming Commission.” It specifically refers to Kalshi allowing users under 21 years to participate on its platform, as well as marketing itself to users on college and university campuses in the state.
What Kalshi NY order seeks to do
In addition to the TRO and injunctions, James’s demand seeks a variety of penalties and repayments that lead to the seismic $36bn figure from her original action in July, which dropped a day after Kalshi’s Second Circuit loss:
- Full accounting of every customer account, with itemized bet lists and total money won or lost by the player
- Restitution to customers who lost money on Kalshi
- Payment of damages and disgorgement of profits
- Penalty of “three times the amount of its gain” and fines of $100,000 “for each offering or attempt to offer sports wagering or mobile sports wagering within or from New York without authorization”
A Kalshi spokesperson responded to media requests with a statement that strikes a more amiable tone than previous comments from the company in its fights with New York:
That statement comes shortly after CFTC Chair Michael Selig said his “door is always open” to attorneys general, even as his body sues a dozen states for taking action against prediction markets:
Kalshi NY troubles extend farther
James’s larger enforcement action is not the only problem Kalshi faces in New York:
- James filed suit earlier this month to compel Kalshi to comply with subpoenas from August related to alleged deceptive marketing based largely on payments to influencers promoting the company.
- The New York City Council in August announced an investigation into Kalshi and other prediction markets operators over “allegations of predatory marketing practices associated with the prediction market industry.”













