Novig sues Ohio, claiming CFTC changed legal landscape after Sixth Circuit ruling

Cleveland, Ohio, where Novig has sued state officials
Image: Mihai_Andritoiu / Shutterstock

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Novig sued Ohio officials in federal court on Nov. 16, alleging the state’s sports betting regulator and its attempts to shut down sports prediction markets violate the U.S. Constitution.
  • The operator also claimed that the CFTC’s rulemaking changed the legal landscape for sports event contracts since the Sixth Circuit ruled in favor of Ohio against Kalshi in September.
  • Ohio is the seventh state sued by Novig, which joins companies including Kalshi, Polymarket, and Underdog in litigation battles against the Buckeye State.

Novig sued Ohio‘s Attorney General and gaming regulators on Monday in a bid to stop them from enforcing the state’s “discriminatory and preempted” sports gambling laws against the company.

In a complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio on Monday, Novig’s federally licensed designated contract market Ludlow Exchange, LLC sued numerous state officials, including:

  • Attorney General Andy Wilson
  • Ohio Casino Control Commission (OCCC) Interim Executive Director Andromeda Morrison
  • OCCC Chair Thomas Stickrath
  • OCCC commissioners

Novig is the latest prediction markets operator to take the OCCC to court, after others including Kalshi and Polymarket, and was one of 10 companies to receive cease-and-desist orders from the regulator in early October.

Like numerous other states, Ohio asserts that sports event contracts equate to illegal online sports gambling without a state license. Its cease-and-desist letters suggested that it could pursue criminal actions if firms did not stop offering sports event contracts in Ohio.

Novig contended in its lawsuit that the threat is unwarranted and unconstitutional, as Ohio’s sports betting laws are preempted by the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) oversight of event contracts.

Novig: CFTC changed landscape since Sixth Circuit ruling

The OCCC sent the cease-and-desist letters soon after the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled in favor of Ohio and Tennessee against Kalshi in late September. Sixth Circuit judges unanimously found that federal commodities law would not preempt the states’ sports betting laws even if sports contracts did qualify as swaps, which the appeals court said they did not.

In its lawsuit against Ohio, Novig argues that the Sixth Circuit ruling in KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler is far from definitive.

“But Schuler is not final: a petition for rehearing en banc is pending before the Sixth Circuit, and three petitions for certiorari presenting the same preemption question are pending before the Supreme Court,” wrote counsel for Novig.

Novig also argues that the CFTC’s interim final rule and notice of proposed rulemaking published on Oct. 9, which it said confirmed that sports-related event contracts are swaps within the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction, “undermine the premise on which Schuler rested” and means that the Sixth Circuit’s ruling against Kalshi “was decided against a different legal landscape.”

New York judge criticized CFTC statements in Novig denial

Novig made that argument in its Ohio filing just six days after a federal judge in New York dismissed the company’s petition for a preliminary injunction against Empire State authorities.

In that ruling, Judge Colleen McMahon wrote that while the CFTC’s notice of proposed rulemaking asserted that CEA swaps include sports-event contracts, its interim final rule stated that casino-style products, including “sports-wagering contracts entered into on a sportsbook and casino games”, are not swaps.

McMahon said those two statements “are inherently contradictory and cannot be reconciled.”

Novig borrows Polymarket ‘interstate commerce’ argument in Ohio

Novig also leaned on the same argument Polymarket used in Ohio: the state’s sports betting licensing requirements are “discriminatory” against interstate commerce and violate the U.S. Constitution’s Commerce Clause.

Like Polymarket, Novig contended that because sports wagering applicants need an in-state place of business or a contractual relationship with an Ohio-based proprietor, the rules would force Novig to fundamentally alter its business model in order to serve Ohio residents.

Holland & Knight partner and gaming practice deputy team leader Joshua Kirschner told SBC Americas last month that Polymarket’s commerce argument, now borrowed by Novig, that the OCCC’s sports betting market is illegally protectionist “seems to miss the point on a few counts.”

Novig continues court offensive against state regulators

Ohio is the seventh state Novig sued since the company began operating a near-nationwide prediction market platform in August.

The formerly state-regulated peer-to-peer betting exchange also lodged lawsuits in:

In its New York lawsuit, Novig acknowledged that its founders always wanted to offer nationwide sports event contracts but did not initially pursue federal designation because the regulatory environment “offered no assurance that sports-related event contracts would be permitted.” After some time as a state-regulated P2P sportsbook, the company shifted to its preferred approach.

Ohio prediction markets litigation state of play

As well as its pre-existing legal battle with Kalshi and its shutdown orders to Novig and Polymarket, the OCCC sent cease-and-desist letters on Oct. 2 to eight other prediction market operators, including Coinbase, Robinhood, and Underdog.

Underdog previously sued Ohio, among other states, in September.

In contrast, Robinhood and Coinbase responded to the OCCC’s letters by agreeing to take down their sports event contracts in Ohio in exchange for guarantees that the regulator would not enforce state gaming laws against the company while appeals are pending.

No posts to display